top of page

Render Unto Caesar

Writer: Rev. Christopher Brademeyer
Rev. Christopher Brademeyer
Nov 8
8 min read

Render Unto Caesar

The 23rd Sunday after Trinity – 11/8/2026

Matthew 22:15-22

Rev. Dr. Christopher W. Brademeyer

 

That portion of God’s holy Word for consideration this morning is our reading from the Holy Gospel according to St. Matthew in the twenty-second chapter with special emphasis on verse 21b which reads as follows:

 

“Then [Jesus] said to them, “Therefore render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”[1]

 

Thus far the Scriptures.

 

In the Name of the Father and of the + Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

 

Politics has a way of bringing out the worst in people. This is particularly true around election time. Friendships are strained, families are divided, and neighbors who have lived alongside one another for decades suddenly find themselves on opposite sides of seemingly insurmountable disagreements. Political arguments can become so heated that we begin to question the character, intelligence, or even the Christian faith of those who disagree with us. It is remarkable how quickly politics can become something much larger than the ordinary business of governing a nation.

For Christians, this presents a particular challenge. We are citizens of two kingdoms. We live in this world, under earthly authorities, and we also belong to the kingdom of God through faith in Jesus Christ. We have responsibilities in both. We are not called to withdraw from the world and its affairs, but neither are we permitted to make the things of this world into our gods.

Our Gospel reading this morning addresses precisely this tension. The Pharisees and Herodians attempt to trap Jesus with a political question. Their question concerns the relationship between the people of God and the governing authorities of this world. Jesus answers with a statement that is both simple and profound: "Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's."

There are three things worth considering from these words of our Lord. First, Christians have earthly responsibilities. The question put to Jesus is whether it is lawful to pay taxes to Caesar. This is not an innocent question. The Jews lived under Roman occupation. Caesar was a foreign ruler, and his government represented a power that many Jews despised. Paying taxes to Rome was a reminder that God's chosen people were subject to a pagan emperor. It was also a practical matter, since the Roman government used those taxes to maintain its military and political control over them. The Pharisees and Herodians hoped to force Jesus into a political predicament. If He said that paying taxes is lawful, He risked alienating the people who resent Roman occupation. If He said that it is unlawful, He risked being accused of rebellion against Rome.

Jesus refused to be caught in their trap. He asked for a denarius and pointed out Caesar's image and inscription upon it. Then He told them to give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar. In other words, the existence of earthly government is not contrary to the Christian faith. Earthly government has a legitimate place in God's ordering of creation. God provides earthly authorities to preserve order, restrain wickedness, administer justice, and protect the lives and property of their citizens.

The Fourth Commandment reminds us that we are to honor our parents and other

A Denarius.
A Denarius.

authorities. The Fourth Commandment does not end when we leave our homes. It extends to those who exercise legitimate authority in the world. The Apostle Paul makes this particularly clear in Romans 13. He writes that governing authorities are instituted by God and that Christians are to be subject to them, pay taxes, and give honor where honor is due. For this reason, we respect our leaders, even when they do not behave respectfully.

In other words, Christians should not regard participation in the political life of their nation as something inherently unchristian. We have responsibilities as citizens. We should pray for those who govern us. We should care about the laws of our nation, the administration of justice, the protection of the innocent, and the welfare of our neighbors. We should vote, serve, and participate in the ordinary affairs of our communities as our vocations permit.

There is nothing wrong with a Christian having political opinions. There is nothing wrong with a Christian supporting a particular candidate, political party, or public policy. There is nothing wrong with Christians seeking to influence the direction of their communities and nation for the good of their neighbors. Indeed, there are times when remaining silent or refusing to participate in the political process would be a failure to love our neighbors.

But that brings us to the second point: Christians must never confuse earthly government with the kingdom of God. The problem with the Pharisees and Herodians is not simply that they are asking a political question. It is that they are trying to use politics as a means of trapping Jesus. They want to force Him into their own political categories. They want to make Him choose a side in their earthly conflict as if it were the ultimate thing. This is something that Christians must be careful to avoid. Politics is important, but it is not ultimate. Political parties are important, but they are not the Church. Political candidates may be good or bad, wise or foolish, competent or incompetent, but not one of them of them is the Savior of the world.

There is a great temptation in every generation to believe that the future of Christianity depends upon the success of a particular political movement. We can begin to think that if only the right people are elected, the right laws are passed, and the right policies are implemented, then the kingdom of God will finally flourish on earth. But this is a confusion of the two kingdoms.

The kingdom of God does not come through elections, legislation, political parties, or military strength. It comes through the preaching of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments. Christ does not establish His kingdom by winning political contests. He establishes it by giving Himself into death for sinners and rising again from the grave.

The Church has survived pagan emperors, hostile governments, religious persecution, corrupt rulers, and political upheaval. It has survived because its Lord is not Caesar. Its Lord is Jesus Christ. This is an important reminder for us Christians. We can become so invested in political outcomes that we begin to measure everything according to political success or failure. We can become so concerned about what is happening in Washington, Bismarck, or even our local communities that we lose sight of what Christ has given to His Church. We can become more interested in the latest political controversy than in the Word of God. We can spend more time discussing the shortcomings of political opponents than confessing our own sins. We can become more passionate about defending our political positions than defending the truth of the Gospel.

And perhaps most dangerously, we can begin to regard our political opponents as our enemies. St. Paul reminds us that our struggle is not against flesh and blood. Our neighbor, even when he is wrong, misguided, or politically opposed to us, is not the enemy whom Christ came to destroy. He is a sinner for whom Christ died. This does not mean that Christians should abandon their convictions or pretend that every political position is equally good. God's Word speaks clearly about the value of human life, marriage, family, justice, and the responsibilities of earthly authority. Christians should not be ashamed to bring those convictions into the public square.

But we must remember that our political opponents are not beyond the reach of God's mercy. We should not allow political disagreements to consume the love that we owe to our neighbors. We must also remember that no political victory can accomplish what only Christ can accomplish. No earthly government can forgive sins. No political party can conquer death. No president, governor, or legislator can reconcile sinners to God. This is the work of Jesus Christ alone.

And this leads us to the third point: Christians belong ultimately to God. Jesus says, "Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's." Caesar has a legitimate claim upon certain things. He has a claim upon taxes, obedience to lawful authority, and the ordinary responsibilities of citizenship. But Caesar does not have a claim upon everything. There are things that belong to God alone.

There is significance concerning the image on the denarius. Jesus asks whose image and inscription are on the coin. They answer, "Caesar's." So Jesus tells them to give Caesar what bears Caesar's image. But whose image do human beings bear? In Genesis, we are told that God created man in His own image. We belong to God. Our lives, our bodies, our souls, and our entire existence are gifts from Him. We are not ultimately defined by our political affiliations, our national identity, our economic circumstances, or our place in society. We are creatures of God. Even more, we are His children by faith. Yes, as Christians, we have been given something even greater than simply being made by God. We have been redeemed by Jesus Christ. We belong to Him because He purchased and won us, not with gold or silver, but with His holy, precious blood and His innocent suffering and death.

Consequently, our highest allegiance belongs to God. If Caesar demands something that belongs to God, then Caesar has gone beyond his proper authority. If earthly rulers demand that we deny Christ, abandon His Word, or disobey His commandments, then we must obey God rather than men. Our citizenship in heaven takes precedence over our citizenship on earth. We must not place our ultimate hope in politics because our hope is already secure in Christ. We need not despair when political events turn against us because Christ remains our Lord. We cannot treat political victories as the coming of God's kingdom because that kingdom has already come to us through the Gospel. We are free to participate in the affairs of this world without making them the center of our existence.

We can vote without believing that an election will save us. We can advocate for good laws without believing that legislation will make us righteous. We can support candidates without treating them as messiahs. We can disagree with our neighbors without treating them as enemies. We can serve our nation faithfully while remembering that our true citizenship is in heaven.

And perhaps most importantly, we can continue to gather here, Sunday after Sunday, to receive the gifts that no earthly government can provide.

Here, Christ gives you His Word. Here, He forgives your sins. Here, He places His own body and blood into your mouths for the forgiveness of sins and the strengthening of your faith. Here, you are reminded that your identity and your future do not depend upon the political fortunes of this world.

Caesar may have his coins. Earthly governments may have their taxes, their laws, and their authority. We have our responsibilities as citizens, and we should fulfill them faithfully. But we belong to God. Our Lord Jesus Christ has claimed you as His own. He has borne our sins, suffered your death, and risen victorious from the grave. His kingdom will not pass away, and His work and promises to you will not fail.

Render to Caesar what is Caesar's. Be faithful citizens. Love your neighbors. Pray for those who govern you. Participate in the affairs of this world for the good of those around you. Render to God what is God's. Give Him your worship, your trust, your allegiance, and your life. For you belong to Him, and He alone is your Savior.


In the holy Name of + Jesus. Amen.

 

 The peace of God that passes all understanding keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Amen.

 


[1] Matthew 22:21b English Standard Version. All further quotations from Holy Scripture are from the ESV.

Comments


    bottom of page